LFG Loud

An LFG Loud study · New York City

You're losing customers to the pizza place down the street. Here's how to stop it.

We searched “pizza near me” from 73 spots across NYC. Only 13 of the 69 places that came up first were the closest. The other 56 did a few simple things differently. You can do them this week.

Tony, founder · November 2, 2026

Share thisFacebookLinkedInXEmail

The map

Same search. A different #1 every few blocks.

We searched from 73 spots, the way a phone does. 69 came back with results, and 69 different pizza places came up first. Tap any dot to see who won there, and how far away they were.

A spot in Queens

“pizza near me” came back with

  1. #1Vincenzo's Pizza

    4.4 stars · 358 reviews · 0.1 mi away

  2. #2Regina's Pizzeria

    4.6 stars · 647 reviews · 0.37 mi away

  3. #3Double J Deli

    4.2 stars · 193 reviews · 0.13 mi away

Tap any dot. Every one has a different #1.

What they did differently

When the farther place came up first, here's what it had.

We looked at every time a pizza place came up ahead of one that was closer to the customer, and checked what it had that the closer place didn't.

94%

Google knew it was a pizza place.

Its main category on Google was "Pizza restaurant." The closer place usually told Google it was an Italian restaurant, a deli, a bar or just "Restaurant". Google shows you for what you say you are.

69%

It was rated 4.5 stars or higher.

Stars mattered far more than how many reviews.

66%

Its hours were listed.

A small group, since almost everyone lists hours. The few who don't get passed.

62%

It had its own website.

Not a delivery app page or an Instagram link. A real site.

60%

The owner had claimed it on Google.

Places nobody had claimed got passed.

52%

It had more reviews.

Barely better than a coin flip. Having 100 or 500 more reviews made almost no difference.

50% would mean it made no difference. These show what the winners had in common, not proof that one thing caused the win.

Do this week

How to show up first this week.

  1. 01

    Tell Google exactly what you are.

    If people search "pizza" for you, your main category should be "Pizza restaurant", not "Italian restaurant". Add the others as extras. It's the biggest difference we found, and it takes two minutes in your Google Business Profile.

  2. 02

    Earn 4.5 stars, not 500 reviews.

    Fix what people complain about, and answer every review. The rating matters more than the count.

  3. 03

    Claim your listing and fill in your hours.

    Search your name on Google Maps. If it says "Own this business?", that's you, unclaimed.

  4. 04

    Get your own website.

    A real site with your menu and ordering, linked from your listing, not a delivery app page.

  5. 05

    Stop paying for review campaigns.

    Ask happy customers for reviews, but don't buy them, and don't expect volume alone to move you.

Share thisFacebookLinkedInXEmail

How we did it

On November 2, 2026, we searched “pizza near me” on Google Maps as a phone would, from 73 evenly spaced spots across Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx and Staten Island, and recorded the top 20 results at each. That gave 1,105 different businesses. Four spots, near parks and water, returned nothing, and some returned fewer than 20. Results change day to day, so this is a snapshot. To see what beats distance, we took every pair of food businesses in the same search whose distance from the searcher differed by more than 0.15 miles. In 31% of 5,653 pairs the farther one ranked higher, and for each trait we counted how often that farther winner had it while the closer place didn't, against the reverse. The data came from DataForSEO. We name no business except as the #1 Google showed at a spot.

Want us to check how Google sees you? Free.

We'll look at your category, listing and website with you, and show you who's showing up instead of you. First 10 clients, through December 31: half off for 6 months. No contract.

Book a free consultation
Text us